BTT #001 · First five testers

Open for feedback

One subscription.
One useful decision?

I built Replace This to compare subscription alternatives honestly—including when keeping what you have makes more sense. Now I’m looking for five people to try one small task.

No signup required to browse. You don’t need to cancel anything.

The five-minute task

  1. Pick one subscription you actually pay for. Search for it on Replace This.
  2. Read its comparison. Would you keep it, consider an alternative, or need more information?
  3. Tell me what helped or got in the way. If your subscription is missing, that is useful feedback too.

What happened when you tried it?

Send me a short note with:

  • The subscription you looked up.
  • Whether the comparison helped you make a decision—and why.
  • Anything missing, confusing, or hard to trust.

“I’d keep what I have” is a useful answer. So is “this didn’t help.” Please don’t send passwords, payment details, or account screenshots.

Email my feedback

Opens your email app. You can also write directly to [email protected]. Feedback does not subscribe you to the newsletter. I’ll summarize the lessons without publishing your name or quoting you unless you agree.

What we’re testing

The hypothesis is that a clear comparison of alternatives and their tradeoffs helps people make a subscription decision. A page visit alone can’t tell us whether that happened.

The goal is five people outside my own testing who complete the task and describe their experience. Five responses are an early learning signal, not proof of demand or a representative survey.

The first week

  • Feedback opens: September 30, 2026.
  • Reporting window: October 1–7, 2026, in America/Chicago (CDT).
  • First review: October 8, 2026.
  • Paid acquisition: $0 planned.
  • First channel: relevant conversations on X and individual invitations.

What goes in the report

Completed tester feedback, useful and confusing parts of the experience, and what I’ll change next. Where available, I’ll report site visits, referrers, and confirmed newsletter subscriptions separately for the same dates.

Build to Traffic and Replace This are separate sites. Cloudflare visits aren’t unique people or returning users, and aggregate traffic does not prove someone completed the task. Owner tests are excluded from the tester count; traffic reports will disclose testing activity when it can’t be separated.

What happened to the 1,000-visitor target?

The original brief proposed 1,000 unique visitors in 30 days. That broader experiment has not started. First we’re testing usefulness with five people, and our current analytics does not establish unique people. Any later traffic experiment will define a metric we can actually measure before its clock starts.

The process

Six steps. No skipping the first.

AI helps us build faster.
This helps us make better bets.

  1. 01
    VALIDATE

    Talk to a specific audience. Study what they already use. Test why they would switch before committing to a large build.

    Find a problem worth solving.

  2. 02
    BUILD

    Use AI to build a focused product. Record the time, tools, costs, and tradeoffs along the way.

    Make the smallest useful thing.

  3. 03
    LAUNCH

    Ship a usable version with measurement in place. A public URL is the starting line.

    Put it in front of people.

  4. 04
    TRAFFIC

    Try a small number of distribution channels. Measure sources and useful visits instead of guessing.

    Test how people find it.

  5. 05
    USERS

    Look for repeat use, conversations, and real problems solved. A visitor is not automatically a user.

    See who comes back.

  6. 06
    REVENUE

    Publish revenue alongside costs. Treat willingness to pay as a hypothesis to test early, then measure actual results.

    Test whether value gets paid for.

A learning loop, not a promise of revenue. Test willingness to pay before you build, too.